Rabbi Pesach Scheiner

Jail vs Fines?

Rabbi Pesach Scheiner
Rabbi Pesach Scheiner

This week’s Torah portion discusses many civil wars such as the punishment for stealing, kidnapping, physical assault etc.  There is a big difference between the Torah’s civil laws and our current modern law in that in the Torah there is no mention of prison as a punishment.  (However, in the Talmud the punishment of prison is found in rare occasions.)  At times, the Torah’s punishments seem more severe than American law.   For example: The punishment for murder and kidnapping in the Torah is the death sentence.  But, at times the Torah’s punishments seem lighter than American law, for example: The punishment of stealing and physical assault are monetary fines.

The commentaries explain that the reason the punishment of prison is not found in the Torah is because the Torah views the punishment of prison as a very harsh punishment since it takes a person out of his natural environment and takes away his freedom.  Many times it also takes away the human need to be productive.

The Rabbis teach us that many of the Torah’s civil laws were only binding when the Temple stood in Jerusalem and there was a Jewish supreme court.  Thus in our times, many times jail sentences are necessary.  However, it would still be good if our judicial system would consider the Torah’s teachings and make it a component in their judicial decisions.

About Rabbi Pesach Scheiner

Rabbi Pesach Scheiner is the Rabbi of Boulder County Center for Judaism. In addition, he teaches extensively throughout Boulder County and is the author of "Finding the Joy in Everyday Living," a book of short chapters explaining the ways to access happiness through appreciation, gratitude, and a sense of purpose.

Check Also

Torah on Thursdays

We are excited to announce a new weekly class on the subject: Jewish Wisdom- Insights Into Topics Connected to the Torah Portion given by Rabbi Scheiner via zoom on Thursday nights from 7:00-7:40 pm.

Pieces Into Peace

We learn in Pirkei Avot, ‘Be like the students of Aaron: Love peace, and pursue peace’ There is so much good advice in this pithy saying.